5 Things People Screw Up When They See a Doctor After a Car Crash
  • Tampa Bay Trial Lawyers Association
  • Central Florida Trial Lawyers Association, Proud Member
  • Polk County Trial Lawyers Association, Former President
  • Motor Vehicle Top 25 Trial Lawyers
  • BBB A+ Rating
  • Lawyers.com 5.0 Client Rating
  • Super Lawyers Rising Star
  • Central Florida Trial Lawyers Association, Proud Member
  • Florida Justice Association - Eagle Member
  • Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent Rating
  • National Top 100 Trial Lawyers
  • The Florida Bar Board Certified Civil Trial

5 Things People Screw Up When They See a Doctor After a Car Crash

I have represented over a thousand people in car crash cases over the years, and one thing I see people screw up over and over again is the way they deal with their healthcare providers following a traffic crash.

1 - Tell your doctor about all your problems, not just the primary complaint

The first thing that I see happen over and over again is when the patient seeks treatment and focuses only on their primary complaint. A seemingly obvious example is if you have a broken arm and go to the emergency room with a bone sticking out of your arm. That is the main thing you will be concerned about, and you’re going to want to get it fixed. The insurance companies take advantage of people who forget to mention other injuries that may not be as immediately noticeable. For instance, you may also be experiencing neck pain that you don’t mention because your initial concern is the most obvious injury. Often times that bone heals, but the neck injury that you neglected to seek treatment for maybe the reason you are unable to work for the rest of your life. When you go to the emergency room complaining about that bone sticking out of your arm, and the healthcare providers document that, but they don’t document the fact that your neck hurts, the insurance company will hold it against you. So the next time you see a healthcare provider two or three weeks later for a follow-up, you mention that your neck has been hurting. The defense lawyers and the insurance company are going to be screaming on the top of the hill, saying, “Wow, their neck didn’t hurt before!”. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been in trial and heard defense lawyers say, “If you hit your thumb with a hammer it hurts immediately; it doesn’t hurt a couple of weeks later.” The very simple way to deal with this is to be sure that when you go see your healthcare provider the first time, every time, that you tell them every part of your body that you have discomfort. If it gets better, that’s an amazing thing, and you can move on. But if it doesn’t get better, then it is documented. That’s super important.

2 - Tell your doctor if you have prior injuries

The second thing people get wrong when they see their healthcare providers after a car crash is they don’t tell their doctor about their prior problems. It is really important that your doctors have a full and complete history of all the issues you’ve had from a health perspective before. This is especially true if you’ve had prior back, neck pain, or anything similar to what you’re complaining of. The healthcare provider can then use that history to exclude the possibility that your current problems are related to the fact that you fell off a balcony in 1982 on spring break, versus the fact that you got hit by a Mack truck.

3 - Provide your PIP and health insurance information

The third mistake I see people make when they see a healthcare provider following a traffic crash is they don’t give their health care provider their insurance information. When you’ve been involved in a traffic crash, you need to give your health care providers both your personal injury protection coverage, that’s your auto coverage, and you need to give them your health insurance coverage. A lot of my clients object to this, thinking, “Wow, somebody else hit me, I shouldn’t have to use my health insurance or my auto coverage!”. In Florida, we have something we refer to as a “no-fault” system for personal injury protection. It is your auto insurance that pays first. After your auto insurance pays, it is up to your health insurance to pay for your medical needs. After that, be sure you provide this information to your medical provider so they can bill accordingly. It is super important, and it helps lawyers, like me, get my clients more money in their pockets after the case is settled.

4 - Tell ALL your doctors about your injuries

The fourth thing people screw up when they see their healthcare providers following a car crash is they assume their doctor is there to only treat one thing. If you’re seeing a chiropractor for your neck and back, and then go see your primary care provider, you should tell them about everything. Don’t assume your chiropractor is the one treating you, so your primary care provider doesn’t need to know about it. It’s really important that all of your health care providers know what kind of treatment you’re getting, how active it is, who’s giving it to you, and when you’re getting it, especially if you’re getting medication. If you compartmentalize this and don’t tell your primary care provider about the fact that you’re seeing a chiropractor, the defense lawyers are going to make a big deal of that if you ever have to go to trial. They will tell the jury that it must not be a big deal because you didn’t bother to tell your own doctor about the fact you were in a car crash. I’ve seen this play out over and over again, and for whatever reason, people compartmentalize what they’re going through. Tell all your health care providers about your medical needs.

5 – Don’t talk law with your doctor, give them a history of the crash but don’t talk about your lawsuit

The fifth thing I see people screw up when they go see their health care provider following a car crash case is that they want to talk to their doctors about their case. Your doctor is not interested in talking to you about your car crash case. Your doctor is there to try to help you feel better, help you recover, and to get back to the “you” that you used to be before the car crash. So, don’t talk to your doctor about your intentions to bring a claim, don’t talk to your doctor about coverage. This is really none of their business. This is something you should be talking to your lawyer about, so try to be sure you separate those things. A lot of doctors hear people talk about this stuff and they won’t have anything to do with a car crash case, because they’ll run for the hills when they think they’re going to get asked questions by a bunch of lawyers. And who could blame them? So just tell your doctors about what happened to you, give them a history of what you’ve been through. You don’t need to talk to them about the fact that you’re going to sue somebody or that you’re going to get money for your accident. That’s ridiculous. Let them focus on treating you and getting you back to “you,” and not worry about litigation, lawyers, and things like that.

I really hope this helps you avoid the pitfalls that people sometimes stumble into following a car crash here in Florida. If you have questions about your case, give us a buzz at 1-800-ASK-DAVE, we’re here to help!


  • Decades of Experience

    Dave has dedicated 15 years and a significant portion of his practice to auto accidents and has well-trained staff in place to help you.

  • We Treat Clients with Excellent Personal Service, Respect & Dignity

    Our core belief is that every detail must be studied, that every adversary must be out prepared and outworked and that every client must be treated like they are family.

  • Personal Injury is All We Do

    Dave is a Florida Bar Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer and focuses his practice on automobile accidents.

Still Have questions?

Watch Our Videos to Learn More


Hear What Our Clients Have to Say
  • Extremely professional lawyer!

    “Extremely professional lawyer!”

    - Kathleen J.
  • I highly recommend their services.

    “John Mark Hundhausen is an awesome attorney. He went above and beyond.”

    - Travis S.
  • Always professional and very helpful.

    “Heather Lineberger does a great job. She is always professional and very helpful.”

    - Christine H.
  • Dave is very caring and attentive to his clients.

    “The way I have been treated since he took on my case is far superior to my experience with any other law firm”

    - Erica C.
  • There is no praise high enough for Dave Dismuke.

    “There is no praise high enough for Dave Dismuke”

    - HMP.

Proven Track Record of Success

  • $10 Million Judgment - Polk County

    Judgment of $10 million for a client due to injuries sustained in an auto accident.

  • $7.25 Million Jury Verdict - Polk County

    Polk County jury awards judgment for wrongful death case.

  • $1.1 Million Settlement - Hillsborough County

    Wrongful death auto accident settlement for $1,100,000.

  • $800 Thousand Auto Accident Settlement - Hillsborough County

    Attorney David C. Dismuke negotiates a settlement in disputed causation surgery.

  • $754 Thousand Auto Accident Settlement - Hardee County

    Attorney David C. Dismuke obtains a verdict in Hardee County.

We Remove the Fear  of Going Through the Process of a Personal Injury Claim

The team at Dismuke Law understands how our clients are affected by accidents and brings that empathy to the courtroom and settlement table every day.